• News/Talk
  • Music
  • Entertainment

Pollution Smells Like Pumpkin Pie

Joshua McNichols

Full Episode Audio
Larger view
This is where sewage goes.
(Joshua McNichols)
View the Slideshow

The holidays are over. Maybe you've joined a gym, started a new, healthy diet. It's been a week since you touched that plate of stale holiday cookies. But for the salmon in Puget Sound, the feast is just beginning. And their diet has been getting much worse. From Seattle, Joshua McNichols explains.


Liana Singh leans over a dock. She dips a plastic bottle into a tributary that feeds Puget Sound. "It's freezing!" Liana is helping the group Sound Citizen look for flavors in the water. Cinnamon and vanilla. Sage and rosemary. All the stuff we ate during the holidays.

Test tubes of Singh's water sample are fed into a mass spectrometer, back at the University of Washington. Jaqui Neibauer is the group's analyst. Her results tell a lot about what people have been eating lately. She points to a graph on her computer. "So here's cinnamon. So the one day after Thanksgiving, the amount nearly doubles. And then four days after Thanksgiving is when we see the spike. And then it kind of tapers off and goes back to a baseline of zero." At its peak, the flavor is so abundant, salmon can smell it.

There's another pulse of cinnamon before Christmas, following everyone's office parties. Chocolate spikes after Valentine's Day. Real vanilla spikes during the holidays, whereas artificial vanilla spikes during summer heat waves. "It's probably from ice cream," explains Neibauer.

The holiday flavor spikes are the most impressive. Neibauer calculated how many cookies people would need to eat in order to put that much flavor into the water. "During the holiday season, there's about 250 thousand cookies per day going into Puget Sound. That means that the average person is eating about 2 cookies per day."

And Neibauer knows those spices were actually eaten. That's because digested spices have their own unique chemical signature.

But doesn't our sewage get cleaned up? Well, yes, but Neibauer says it's more complicated than that. And that's how I ended up on a giant catwalk at King County's West Point Sewage Treatment Plant. Tour guide Casey Plank points down to a bubbly brown liquid coursing down an open trough. "We add a whole lot of bacteria, that makes it brown. We add oxygen, that makes it bubbly. This right here is a big cleaning party."

The water flows through one of the last defenses before our waste goes back into the Sound. It's a giant cesspool of bacteria. "It's a 50-50 gamble whether the bacteria are actually going to eat something," says Plank. "They may break something down, they may not. You have to assume that what's going down your drain, it's going to make a stop at a treatment plant, but then it's going to go back out. There's no magic happening here. Nothing just disappears. It is well known that if we're testing water from sewer lines, you are gonna find aspirin, medicines, cleaning products. Anything you can test for - you're gonna find it."

And scientists are finding more than just spices. Just ask oceanographer Rick Keil. "In a typical sample from Puget Sound, we'll see two or three hundred different chemicals that are in the water sample," says Keil.

Keil founded the group Sound Citizen. He wants to know what's killing Puget Sound. In the last couple of years, the Sound has developed huge dead zones. Bottom feeding fish are turning into hermaphrodites and can't reproduce. Orca whales are dying in unprecedented numbers. It's really hard to pinpoint specific causes, but Keil suspects it has to do with all the chemicals in the water. And the chemicals are coming from us.

"It's hard to think that just living your average life is having some harmful impact somewhere," concedes Keil. "The initial reaction was often 'I don't want to hear about it, it makes me depressed.'"

But then Keil had the idea of testing for spices. Now, when he and his students go around to schools, they can talk about the Cinnamon-flavored waters of Puget Sound. He waits for the audience to make the connection to the more toxic chemicals in our daily lives. "We can talk about the impact we have on the environment without feeling sad," he says. "It's not about everything being bad, it's about thinking of the connected nature of the earth and thinking about the ramifications of everything that we do."

Then he tells folks to read labels and avoid certain ingredients. People can also take their expired drugs, even aspirin, back to a pharmacy instead of flushing them down the toilet. And if they want to, they can join his volunteer army of sample collectors.

Out on the dock, I ask him the question no journalist can resist. Do the salmon caught during a spike in cinnamon taste better? Rick looks out at the water. He says he doesn't eat these fish. They're too contaminated.


Ingredients to Avoid for Ocean Health

-ethylene glycol
-diethylene glycol

By scanning the ingredients listed on common household products, you can avoid many of these unhealthy pollutants. Not everything nasty is listed on the label, but this list will help you reduce your health risk and environmental impact.


  • Comment | Refresh

  • By Barcode Generator

    From City, 03/10/2011

    There is need for providing secure and environmentally sound method for disposal. Drug recycling programs is considered to be expensive one so there is need for alternative methods.

    By Barcode Generator


    There is need for providing secure and environmentally sound method for disposal. Drug recycling programs is considered to be expensive one so there is need for alternative methods. Barcodes http://www.barcodelabelsoftware.net

    By James Garlough

    From Minneapolis, MN, 01/12/2009

    That's great, but wholly inadequate. This retailer has over 5700 locations worldwide, most in the U.S., but also in many countries throughout the world. Until U.S. and International law is changed to require the big players (like my former employer) to provide effective disposal of outdated drugs, they will continue to flush them. Sadly, there is not yet an ideal technique for disposal of these highly refined and concentrated substances. Even when burned, they leave many deposits in the air and in their ashes, which are often land-filled and ultimately, as ground water perks through the ashes some of the compounds, now altered by heat, still end up in our water and air. We should fund good research into inexpensive ways to neutralize these compounds so they can be put back into the environment safely or reused. Personally, I feel it should be the manufacturer's responsibility to develop effective methods to deal with their product in the environment before introducing the compound to the public. But, with greed such as it is, that type of forward thinking and responsible corporate leadership does not exist.

    By Joshua McNichols

    From Seattle, WA, 01/10/2009

    Awareness of this issue has pushed many pharmacies to try alternative methods of disposal. Some send old drugs to a specialized municipal incinerator. Others participate in drug recycling programs (I find that amazing. How do they ensure quality?). Either way, there are plenty of options out there for responsible pharmacies.

    By James Garlough

    From Minneapolis, MN, 01/10/2009

    For many years I have heard well meaning people like Rick Keil tell us to take our expired drugs back to the pharmacy. Having worked for a national chain store with pharmacies in every location (thousands of locations), and having witnessed hundreds of well meaning people bringing their expired drugs in to the pharmacy, I question the wisdom of this statement. Why? Because it was the official policy of the company that expired drugs were to be…wait for it…flushed down the toilet. My toilet, the store’s toilet; the chemical slurry goes to the same place, our waters. We need a better solution than just moving the expired product to a different toilet as that solves nothing.

  • Post a Comment: Please be civil, brief and relevant.

    Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. Weekend America reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air if they are extra-interesting. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.

      Form is no longer active


    You must be 13 or over to submit information to American Public Media. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited email and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Download Weekend America

Weekend Weather

From the January 31 broadcast

Support American Public Media with your Amazon.com purchases
Search Amazon.com:
 ©2015 American Public Media